Acne scarring

By Dr. Matete Mathobela5 min read

Acne scarring

  • Acne has a prevalence of over 90% among adolescents and persists into adulthood in approximately 12%–14% of cases.

  • Inflammatory acne (papules,pustules,nodules and cysts) lesions can result in permanent scars, the severity of which may depend on the acne grade and delays in treatment.

  • Severe scarring caused by acne is associated with substantial physical and psychological distress, particularly in adolescents

  • Scarring can occur as a result of damage to the skin during the healing of active acne.

  • There are two basic types of scars depending on whether there is a net loss(atrophic) or gain of collagen (hypertrophic scars).

  • 80-90 % of people with acne scars have scars associated with a loss of collagen (atrophic scars) compared to a minority who show hypertrophic scars and keloids.

Atrophic Scars:

  • Atrophic acne scars are more common than keloids and hypertrophic scars with a ratio 3 : 1.

  • They have been subclassified into ice pick, boxcar, and rolling scars

  • Sometimes the 3 different types of atrophic scars can be observed in the same patients and it can be exceedingly difficult to differentiate between them

Ice pick scars:

  • Ice-pick scars comprise 60 to 70 percent of atrophic scars

  • these narrow, less-than-2mm, v-shaped epithelial tracts have a sharp margin that extends vertically to the deep dermis or subcutaneous tissue

  • their depth of involvement makes ice-pick scars resistant to conventional skin resurfacing options

Box scars:

  • boxcar scars comprise 20 to 30 percent of atrophic scars

  • these scars are wider, 1.5- to 4.0mm, round-to-oval depressions with sharply demarcated vertical edges

  • shallow boxcar scars (0.1–0.5mm) are amenable to skin resurfacing treatments, whereas deep boxcar scars (≥0.5mm) are resistant

Rolling scars:

  • rolling scars comprise 15 to 25 percent of atrophic scars

  • these scars are the widest and may reach up to 5mm in diameter

  • Fibrous anchoring of the dermis to the subcutis results in superficial shadowing and a smooth fall and rise appearance of the scars

  • treatment must focus on correction of the subdermal component

Treatment options:

  • early and aggressive treatment of active acne remains the best way to prevent or limit acne-related scarring

  • it is also of vital importance to ensure active acne has been treated before approaching scar treatment so as not to create a cycle where active lesions continue to

  • scar in areas already addressed

  • treatment of generalized atrophic acne scars involves a field approach, and includes

Dermabrasion:

  • Dermabrasion utilizes a manual hand or machine-driven source to remove the epidermis with or without part of the dermis

  • the procedure allows the dermatologist to precisely define scar edges

  • it is best used for well-defined scars with distinct borders or broad-based scars with indistinct borders, but not for ice-pick or deep boxcar scars

  • Dermabrasion seeks to reorganize the papillary dermal collagen without injury to the reticular dermis leading to new collagen formation

  • complications include significant pain, scarring, pigment changes, and milia formation

  • after treatment, patients will experience increased sun sensitivity for several months, and unprotected skin can often develop hyperpigmentation

Chemical peels:

  • chemical peels are used to treat small, depressed scars but not ice-pick or deep boxcar scars

  • they induce injury to the skin that stimulates collagen remodelling and are categorized as superficial, medium, and deep based on the depth of the injury

  • superficial peels, such as lactic acid, salicylic acid, glycolic acid, Jessner solution, and 10 to 25% trichloroacetic acid, only affect the epidermis

  • medium depth peels, such as combined Jessner solution with 35 to 50% trichloroacetic acid affect the epidermis and papillary dermis

  • in most patients, medium depth peels result in moderate clinical improvement (51–75% clearance), with transient post inflammatory hyperpigmentation resolving within three months

  • The chemical reconstruction of skin scars (CROSS) technique:

  • the cross technique is indicated for icepick and narrow boxcar scars

  • it involves a high-strength trichloroacetic acid (tca) peel (65–100%) applied to the base of the scar to ablate the epithelial wall and to promote dermal remodeling

  • the degree of clinical improvement is proportional to the number of courses of cross treatment, with good improvement after 3 to 6 courses reported in more than 90 percent of cases

  • Fractional 1,550nm erbium-doped laser has been shown to outperform cross for the treatment of rolling scars, but no difference has been observed for icepick scars.

Microneedling:

  • microneedling (collagen induction therapy) utilizes tiny needles to puncture the skin multiple times, creating microclefts that penetrate into the dermis

  • the trauma in the dermis initiates wound healing and growth factor release, leading to collagen production and deposition in the upper dermis

  • skin needling renders facial skin smoother and improves rolling acne scars

  • similar to subcision, the tethered rolling scars can be overcome by greater collagen and elastin deposition induced by needling

  • the full result may take 8 to 12 months as the deposition of new collagen takes place slowly

  • one important advantage is that the epidermis remains intact, eliminating most of the risks of chemical peeling or laser resurfacing

  • furthermore, microneedling provides a clear channel for the efficient absorption of topical agents, including platelet-rich plasma (prp), which can improve cosmetic results

  • results of microneedling treatment were comparable to the non-ablative fractional laser in one study

Other treatment options:

  • radiofrequency

  • laser

  • fillers for isolated scars (in soft atrophic rolling or boxcar scars)

  • punch excision and punch elevation (for ice-pick and boxcar scar)

  • subcision (best suited for rolling acne scars)